Slime: How Algae Created Us, Plague Us, and Just Might Save Us
Reviewed by: John Stokdijk
Ruth Kassinger’s enthusiasm for her chosen subject, Slime: How Algae Created Us, Plague Us, and Just Might Save Us, is obvious throughout her book. Imagine someone getting excited about algae. But it did make her book enjoyable to read.
My fascination became this book. It is the story of my journey— by phone, plane, car, boat, drone, and scuba fins, across the US and around the globe from Canada to Wales to South Korea— to understand how algae, the most powerful organisms on the planet, influence our lives, for better and for worse, and what role they will play in our future.
Kassinger begins her story at the very beginning, “3.7 billion years ago, about 750 million years after the planet coalesced from cosmic dust.” She takes us on a long journey of transformation that gave us our beautiful blue home. Algae played a significant role and as the world changed the algae evolved.
Of the four sections in the book, Section I, In the Beginning, the long history of the earth, was my favorite.
Section II, Glorious Food, was my least favorite as I am not a foodie. But I did appreciate learning about EQ. Again, our deep past is interesting.
...a measurement called the Encephalization Quotient or EQ, which is the ratio of brain size to body size...
The latter’s direct descendants in the Rift Valley, Homo habilis (the earliest members of the Homo genus who lived roughly 2.4 million years ago), had an EQ of 57. Homo erectus lived from about 1.9 million years to 150,000 years ago, and individuals who lived at the end of that period had EQs of 63.
But, when— and where— did Homo sapiens with fully modern, EQ 100 brains evolve? It certainly must have happened at a time and place where algae-concentrated DHA and iodine were on the menu. In other words, along the shore and, most likely, along the ocean shore.
Section III, Practical Matters, details current uses of algae. These range from feedstock for plants and animals, an emulsifier, a salad ingredient, a source of energy and more. I was impressed by the depth and breadth of Kassinger’s knowledge and, again, her enthusiasm for all things algae.
I felt uneasy reading Section IV, Algae and the Changing Climate. Some members of the Ajijic Book Club had expressed an interest in lighter topics, a desire to avoid doom and gloom, no heavy stuff. Section IV did not meet those expectations.
In the Epilogue, Kassinger writes,
It’s easy to feel depressed, even defeated, by the continuing and seemingly unstoppable degradation of our environment.
Her conclusion does not encourage me.
There will be no single, quick fix to our intertwined environmental crises, and it will take many small measures that have a significant effect in the aggregate. A 10 percent reduction in carbon dioxide emissions here; a 15 percent reduction in methane emissions there; a 5 percent drawdown of atmospheric carbon in the future— pretty soon you’re talking about real environmental relief.
I struggled to finish reading this book but for a reason unrelated to it. I was reading Section II when the coronavirus crisis hit, completely diverting my attention. Perhaps for a time my range of interest will be more narrow, or perhaps not.
2 months ago — John Stokdijk
Slime Discussion Questions
What were your experiences with algae, that you were aware of, before you read this book? How about seaweed (macroalgae)?
I knew very little about algae before reading this book. I did not know that seaweed was macroalgae. I did have some knowledge about the potential of algae as a source of energy.
Have you ever had to care for a pond? Or just lived near one? What was that like?
We had a pond on our farm. But I remember the water being mostly clear as it was fed by a small stream. Only when the stream dried up during a hot summer did the pond turn green with algae.
You probably knew that the Earth was once almost completely covered in ice. Were you able to follow the complicated story of how algae caused the Ice Age? And led to the evolution of humans?
I would fail if tested on this, but I found this very interesting.
In Japan, people eat on average about 14 grams (a couple of tablespoons?) of seaweed (nori) a day. Could it be the Omega-3 oil that helps them have one of the longest life expectancies of any country? Should we be eating more seaweed? Are you?
The possible impact of seaweed on Japanese life expectancy is interesting. Even so, no I will not be eating more seaweed. But I do eat flaxseed as a source of Omega-3.
Were you surprised to learn that Spanish conquerors of Mexico in the 16th century found the Aztecs eating spirulina? Do you eat spirulina? Why, or why not?
Learning this about the Aztecs was interesting but I do not eat spirulina. Generally, I do not eat dietary supplements as I do not seem to need them. Fortunately, after my last medical examination, my doctor informed me that I was in very good health for my age.
Can you name 5 products that you probably use every day, made with carrageenan or alginate?
How is growing salmon on land, in tanks, as is happening in Vancouver, BC,
different/better than traditional fish farming?
I do not know enough about this to answer the question.
We already make athletic shoes from algae, but the market for shoes and other plastics doesn’t make much of a dent in our use of fossil fuels. We need algae gasoline. Why don’t we have it?
It is mostly about the economics of the matter. We want a clean planet and we want cheap gasoline. We want a clean planet and we want convenient plastic products.
How much do you know about the process by which ethanol is made from corn, which makes up 10% of gasoline we use in our cars in the US, by law? How does that compare to the way Algenol makes ethanol? So why aren’t we using it now?
Ethanol from corn as a source of energy is a whole other story deserving a book of its own.
Have you used any of the personal care products produced by Solazyme/TerraVia? Algenist for the skin? How about chocolate chip cookies with algae oil (Thrive) instead of butter, available at Walmart (probably not here)?
I think I have seen ads for Thrive on TV, sounds familiar.
Have you ever seen “watermelon snow?” Or, more likely, especially if you’re from BC, “rock snot?”
Were you able to get through Chap. 6, Sec. 4: Making Monsters? Or did learning about how many MORE ways humans are ruining the planet make you too anxious and/or depressed?
I appreciated the knowledge but I try not to react emotionally.
Was your anxiety alleviated somewhat by what you learned in Chapter 7: Geoengineering? Why or why not?
No. I am skeptical and I am concerned about negative unintended consequences. Sometimes solutions to one problem are the source of a new, very different problem.
Apparently, algae periodically remove so much carbon dioxide from the atmosphere that large ice sheets form in the Northern Hemisphere. So, since algae are so effective at cooling our climate, can we enlist them to do so now?
What did you think of the author’s scenario of “some tribes of Homo sapiens, having survived drastic climate change, will be clustered along the northern shores of Canada and the Eurasian continent, shaded by banana and palm trees, warning their children not to swim in the soupy scum that lines the word’s coastlines or play in the rotting seaweed washed up on the beaches”?
I think the author’s scenario is, unfortunately, a reasonable possibility.
The Epilogue offers examples of our “best hopes for the future.” Name 5 ways algae are being used now, or could be used, for our benefit.
The last sentence of the Epilogue reads “Algae: They created us, sustain us, and, if we’re both clever and wise, they can help save us.” Homo Sapiens are indeed clever. But I doubt that we are wise.